Closer to Stone by Simon Cleary

 After arriving in Casablanca, Baz (Sebastian) feels exhausted and disoriented. The teaming crowds, the beggars, and the bustling markets assault his senses. This is just the beginning of his alienation, however. His journey to find his brother, Jack, takes him on a dark and increasingly disconcerting mission, deeper and deeper into the desert.

Raised in the shadow of his older brother Jack, Baz envied his brother’s shining confidence and spirit. Jack, like most first-born children, was the favourite of his parents, and Baz took this hard, especially after their mother died. He felt conflicted towards Jack, especially after he hesitated before diving from high cliffs into a deep rock pool, and Jack actually pushed him. The boys taunted him before that, and he was petrified:

‘In my own way I responded heroically. I endured. I remained resolute in my petrification, and eventually the mocking lost its intensity and the beat grew ragged, before finally disintegrating. In the calm after that, the silence. I forgot I was afraid.

It was almost tranquil up there on the ledge.

Then Jack pushed me.’

Baz’s father sends him on this journey, asking him to leave his career as a sculptor behind for a time, because Jack has disappeared from his UN peacekeeping force. Is Jack a deserter? Has he ‘gone native’? This is not the Jack, their father, a former veteran himself and proud of the family’s military history, knows. Baz must bring him back - back to his senses and back to his family.

Naive and alone, Baz suffers betrayal, and finds himself forced to deal with Jack’s Captain, a nasty Colonel Blimp type, who at least sends him out with a fellow officer, Logan, to try and find him. Does he have ulterior motives, however? It’s a long and increasingly anguished journey for Baz, but he finds some comfort in the company of the beautiful teacher, Sophia, who is much better at understanding the Muslim Algerians. Baz seems unsympathetic when he refuses to give his antibiotics to a sick local girl, and Sophia gets very angry with him. Here, he’s showing his Western pragmatic attitude, because he wants to keep the pills in case he and Sophia need them, rather than thinking of whether the native girl needs them more.

Simon Cleary describes the desert evocatively. You feel that you’re actually travelling with the pair as they navigate the sweeping sand dunes, and the small desert towns and deal with the Muslim men, who Baz finds increasingly difficult to understand. The budding romance with Sophia is beautifully done, and you feel for Baz when he resents her loving Jack first. 

The shocking climax of the book will stay with you for some time. The novel deals with huge themes of sibling love and rivalry, trauma, grief and redemption. The conflict and misunderstandings between Islam and the West and between Islam and Catholicism are also major themes, and I found the discussions of theology interesting. This luminously written novel will provide you with much to think about.

NB: You may need some tissues. I actually cried at the end!



Comments