Frequently Auto-Approved
Reviews Published Challenge Participant

Friday, August 19, 2005

Daughter of Time by Josephine Tey

As the old saying goes: 'this is an oldie but a goodie'. Daughter of Time is an excellent defence of Richard III and a much more entertaining way of learning some history than reading a dry textbook.

Tey's hard-working detective, Grant, lies in bed in hospital at the beginning of the book with a leg injury. Bored and missing his police work, when his bright actress friend, Marta, gives him some portraits to study concerning historical mysteries, he becomes intrigued. The portrait of Richard III surprises him. He has long been told, like the rest of us, that Richard was a monster who would do anything to claim the throne including murdering the little Princes, his own brother's children.
When he looks at the portrait, however, he sees the face of a 'judge', someone of integrity.

The two nurses who are entertaining characters - the bossy 'Amazon' and the timid 'Midget' - agree with him and decide to help him discover the truth about Richard. One of them lends him a book by Sir Thomas More, the book on which the legend about Richard was based. As he reads this he remembers that More lived during Henry VIII's time and never knew Richard at all. He determines to discover the truth.

Marta enlists the aid of her young American friend, Carradine, who wants to make his name by writing a historical book. Carradine loves all this and Grant's discussions with him help him greatly in his development of a new theory about Richard.

Although Tey's detective is ill which rather limits the action in this book, she manages to fill the novel with interesting characters and tell an excellent story.

Wednesday, August 03, 2005

From the Outback to Fairyland

A STORY DREAMT LONG AGO by Phillis McDuff

Phyllis McDuff has written a fascinating tale about a daughter who searches for her mysterious mother's past and finds out much more about herself along the way. A quintessentially Australian migrant story it involves a country childhood, an adolescence spent in a schizophrenic whirl between Australia and Austria and discovery of a family's true past. Most of all, however, it is the story of Bettina McDuff, a tremendously strong and enigmatic character who escaped from the Nazi's to make a new life in Australia.

Bettina came from an extremely wealthy family with a luxurious house in Austria. When the Nazi's captured Austria this wealth was requisitioned and Bettina managed somehow to escape here. Used to having all the domestic duties done by servants and a former pupil at a famous English private school, in Australia she found herself poor and had to take any work she could. She worked on a farm and met Joe, a much older man who lived nearby in a fairly open log cabin. They married and as they managed farming together life slowly improved.

Phyllis enjoyed her country childhood and got on better with her easy-going father than her temperamental mother. After Joe died Phyllis found herself torn between Australia and Austria during her teenage years as her mother often decided to take the children back to her homeland. In more formal and cultivated Austria she became a debutante going to balls and dances every night, enjoyed the opera, shopped with her mother and ate Viennese cakes.

Her mother grew increasingly erratic and strange as she grew older refusing to talk about her past when Phyllis asked questions. But there were many odd events which made Phyllis long to know more, such as the disappearance of Bettina's brother during the war, whispered conversations in Vienna amongst family and friends and the provenance of some drawings allegedly by Picasso.

Finally she and her mother make peace and she learns more about her family but some questions will always remain unanswered.

Although simply told the writing is very lucid and this is such an enjoyable book that it is well-worth reading. Highly recommended!